‘Star Wars: The Last Jedi’ is a Rebel Yell For Fans of Rebel Scum

The Latest Movie in the Franchise Delivers on its Feel Good Promise

I walked into the theatre ready to like The Last Jedi if for no other reason than Carrie Fisher’s appearance in it.

I admit my bias and my sentimentality. For me, the latest installments in the Star Wars saga have been about women, about what I will always believe was the sexism and patriarchy of the 1970s keeping a fascinating character, Leia, in a supporting role, about a princess re-emerging as a General, about an orphaned girl fighting and holding her own against a trained Sith apprentice. Since this and the prominence of PoCs were what I wanted, The Last Jedi satisfied.

This installment continues the examination of inner conflict that The Force Awakens began. Rey is kneeling at the foot of a reluctant and reclusive Luke Skywalker. Patricidal Kylo Ren is rent in two by what should have been his definitive turn to the dark side. General Organa is continuing her lifelong mission of subverting oppressive regimes while wrestling with the idea that her son has turned. Finn is still a First Order deserter who has to battle his me-first-and-f*ck-all-y’all-I’m-saving-myself instinct. Luke is still out here battling the same demons he’s been battling since the first installment: himself and all of his big, huge feelings. Poe Dameron, too, is battling his impulses to achieve his goals.

What the movie does well is link each of these individual journeys to the larger over-arching narrative. The cogs fit well. By the end of the movie, most of these characters reach new personal milestones or realizations, some more satisfying than others. Inner conflict becomes a window to loss, hubris, and fear. The audience is asked to think about failure and what it means in the trajectory of a life, of a war, of a government.

It seemed, at times, particularly poignant to examine how we fight back against failure in the current shitshow that is our government. How does one rebel against all odds? What is the personal responsibility of each of us in response to the call? These are questions the franchise has been directly addressing at least since Padmé. This installment is unrelenting in that regard while, somehow, simultaneously retaining a dry humor that acts as a pressure valve.

This humor does not just come from the expected characters like Poe or Finn, though it does come from them. There is a scene in which Luke and Rey are talking about the nature of the Force. It may be the funniest few seconds in the entire franchise. There are small, beautiful moments scattered throughout the film like that. They reminded me that while the nerdom is serious business, as evidenced by the massive line and casual cosplay in the theatre, it is, at its heart, entertainment.

In the theatre I was in, we laughed, we clapped, we cheered, we awwwww-ed, and I heard more than one person admit to crying during the film. I didn’t, but I came close watching General Organa. We know Leia, though untrained, is sensitive to the Force. We also know that this was Carrie Fisher’s last reprisal of her iconic role. I don’t think the passing of the (strong woman) torch was meant to be this literal, but death rarely cares about our intentions so it was. Fisher, as Leia, got to see Rey pursue her training with Luke. This was not bloodline nepotism, but pure talent. I got to see a world where daughters do not understand that there was a time when all the Jedi were men, were white, were not them. And, yes, though I’d love a movie in which the Jedi are all #blackgirlmagic and light sabers, I cannot pretend that Leia, as a princess and as a general—especially where those Venn diagram circles overlap—was not inspiring to me as a child and as a woman.

I think the emotional weight of this legacy, and of others, was purposefully and deftly communicated through the use of silence. When the noise drops out of a theatre of hundreds, you feel it. If the Force is about balance, and all of the movies have been, on some level, about seeking that balance, then the decision to embrace both the state of the art sound system and the quiet is a wise choice.

There are things I did not like about the movie: a forced tension between characters, a moment when I questioned the internal logic of the universe we were in, and an overly didactic subplot. Even though these things are outweighed by what I enjoyed, they are worth mentioning.

There are two simultaneous, intertwined plots happening: white people exploring their own inner lives, and PoCs trying to solve real-world problems in real-world time. Yes, I’m oversimplifying, but this is, at its heart a space western and so I feel justified. John Boyega’s Finn and Kelly Marie Tran’s Rose risk their lives trying to get the MacGuffin while Rey, in a number of ways, explores the Force on an island with Skywalker. Yes, they are still on the island even though stakes were high (looks at Roy Moore election results and deep sighs).

Oscar Isaac’s Poe Dameron explores much of the same territory that the franchise covered with Han Solo. Yes, he’s handsome. Yes, he’s a lovable rogue. Yes, he has a heart of gold and poor impulse control. No, he doesn’t respect female authority in any way whatever even in the face of evidence that he should simply fall back.

***The lightest of spoilers in the next paragraph***

I was also somewhat annoyed by the buddy-cop-turned-possible-romantic-tension between Finn and Rose. This is the Speed principle. As a young Sandra Bullock said in the classic 1994 film Speed, “relationships that start under intense circumstances, they never last.” And, no, Finn and Rose aren’t Facebook-official or anything, but the movie seeks to sow the seeds of attraction. Why? So Rey can be a monk? [deep sigh]. So we have to navigate the sexual politics and tension in the next installment? [deeper sigh]. So we can watch Rey and Finn repeat Anakin and Padmé’s clandestine relationship minus, of course, the pedophiliac grooming? [deepest of sighs].

***end of light spoilers***

Even given these things, it is overall, a good movie worth watching. And timely, as our own modern-day First Order takes roots.

Are you following Black Nerd Problems on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr or Google+?


  • Show Comments

  • Evil Ninja (@EvilNinjaX24)

    Every time Carrie Fisher was on screen… EVERY SINGLE TIME… I felt verklempt. When [SPOILERS] she was floating in space, pre-force-ex-machina, it was really bad. When her and Luke were talking… man, look. When the credits were rolling, and “in loving memory of our Princess” hit the screen, a ninja straight got emotional for a bit. Hell, just typing that and recalling it… [END SPOILERS]

    Overall, I loved it. I had issues with it here and there (the ending, for example; the over-9000 power level of some of the Force shenanigans was another issue), but it was good.

    [SPOILER] Also, if Rey doesn’t construct herself a saber staff for/in the next movie, I’m going to be terribly disappointed at the story trajectory, ’cause it’s been SHOWN she’s talented with a staff.[END SPOILER]

    • Lee Jones

      Being talented with a staff doesn’t mean squat. It requires a different fighting style.

  • Shawn Wildermuth


    I too am disappointed Rose and Finn got together (I didn’t want Finn and her to be a thing either). I really thought they were headed to Rose and her sister being lovers (instead of sisters). That married with Leia and Vice Admiral also had a heavy couple vibe going. They could introduce their second and third gay couples (since Rogue one). But alas, they played it safe. But I did LOVE the movie. So it’s not that big of a deal.

  • Lee Jones

    [“This was not bloodline nepotism, but pure talent. I got to see a world where daughters do not understand that there was a time when all the Jedi were men, were white, were not them.”]

    Where you speaking of the Original Trilogy? Because there were women of color who were a part of the Jedi Order in the Prequel Trilogy.

    [“No, he doesn’t respect female authority in any way whatever even in the face of evidence that he should simply fall back.”]

    Poe respected LEIA ORGANA. He did not respect Holdo (or whatever her name was). Why do people keep forgetting this?

    I didn’t like it. Nor did I like “The Force Awakens”. This is disappointing to me, considering that I’m a fan of Rian Johnson’s 2012 movie. And it’s interesting that the first two movies of the Sequel Trilogy are the only two Star Wars movies that I TRULY DISLIKE. As for “The Last Jedi” . . .

    I had hoped that Rian Johnson, who had made “Looper” would make a better film than J.J. Abrams. He didn’t. One, he copied so much from the Original Trilogy films. Too much, as far as I’m concerned. J.J. Abrams has nothing on Johnson. Worse, the latter even used his Cid character from “Looper” as a template for Kylo Ren. Who, by the way, STILL came off as a second-rate Anakin Skywalker. Rey not only remained a Mary Sue, but also became something of an idiot for allowing herself to be manipulated in that way. Hmmm . . . perhaps she is no longer a Mary Sue. But the character of Marie Tico seemed to be one.

    Judging by the addition of Rose, I gather the Disney suits are determined that Rey, a white woman and Finn, a black man, will never become romantically involved. As you can see, I’m not a Reylo fan. This story arc involving Rey and Ren seemed so contrived. It probably would have worked if they had known each other a lot longer than they did or if the time span between “The Force Awakens” and “The Last Jedi” had been more than a day or two. But that didn’t happen. And because of the very shot period of time between the two movies, this scenario DID NOT work for me. And yet, fans are squealing over the possibility of a toxic and rushed relationship like Rey/Ren as if it was the ultimate sci-fi romance.

    Poe Dameron proved to be an even bigger idiot than Rey. Johnson turned him into a cliche of a hotshot pilot, straight out of “Top Gun”. Rose annoyed me because she continually undermined Finn’s choices by being self righteous and controlling. Snoke is just as big of a mystery as he was in the 2015 film. We know nothing about him. And he came off as a second-rate Palpatine. I also noticed there were two situations that seemed straight from “Thor: Ragnarok” featuring the death of a major supporting character and a small group of survivors. Is Disney creating basic narrative situations to be used in many of their movies and different franchises?

    I don’t mind if Rey’s parents were “nobodies from no where”. But where does she fit in the Skywalker saga? If the Sequel Trilogy is supposed to be a continuation of the Skywalker family saga, then why do the trilogy’s two biggest protagonists – Rey and Finn – have no blood connection to the family? Why not simply claim this trilogy as something completely separate from the Prequel and Original trilogies? Why? I suspect that Kennedy and Lucasfilm wanted the old characters – Luke, Han and Leia – as a nostalgia factor to draw in the established fan base and nothing else. I could have accepted Rey’s background a lot better if this third trilogy had not been specifically connected to the other two.

    I get the feeling that Kathleen Kennedy wants to break away from Lucas’ work as much as possible. Or that she’s trying to reshape the Star Wars saga into what she wants by slowly eradicating Lucas’ work, while exploiting the nostalgia factor at the same time. Does Disney’s purchase of Fox mean that the studio, along with Lucasfilm will finally have the opportunity to reshape or reboot the first six films?

    Anything good from this movie? Well . . . visually, it looked good. The music was well handled, but I don’t recall anything particularly memorable. John Boyega gave his usual first-rate performance. Benecio del Toro was amusing. And Domhall Gleeson actually made me feel sorry for General Hux by the end of the film. The character realized that he was stuck with the whining man child as his “supreme leader”.

  • Lee Jones

    [“Luke is still out here battling the same demons he’s been battling since the first installment: himself and all of his big, huge feelings.”]

    That is a battle that everyone has to endure throughout his or her life.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *